Files
paseo/plan.md
Mohamed Boudra 5d24e0eee8 Investigation: Image attachments are broken
Tested image attachment flow via Playwright MCP. Found three issues:

1. Agent creation silently drops images (by design - TODO in code)
2. Web platform fails base64 encoding (expo-file-system not available)
3. Server buildAgentPrompt only creates text summary, never sends bytes

Added fix tasks to plan.md and detailed report in
REPORT-image-attachment-investigation.md.

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2025-12-29 09:03:58 +07:00

13 KiB

Plan

Context

Improvements to the new agent screen in the app.

Agent Assignment

  • Default: All tasks are done by Codex
  • Testing tasks: Use agent=claude for Playwright MCP testing

Tasks

  • Iteration 1: Remember the last used config in the new agent screen.

    • Restore the previous behavior where the config was persisted.
    • When user creates an agent, save the selected config (provider, model, mode, working directory, host).
    • On next visit to new agent screen, pre-populate with last used config.
    • Done (2025-12-28 23:35): WHAT: packages/app/src/app/agent/new.tsx:77-592 now builds initial values only from provided params and persists form preferences on create; packages/app/src/hooks/use-agent-form-state.ts:309-356 adds explicit persistence helper. RESULT: new agent screen rehydrates last-used config and saves selections on create. EVIDENCE: Not run (not requested).
  • Iteration 2: Show the selected permissions mode in the agent selector trigger.

    • The agent selector dropdown trigger currently shows provider and model (e.g., "Claude · auto").
    • It should also display the selected permissions mode (e.g., "Claude · auto · Plan").
    • Update the trigger label to include the mode.
    • Done (2025-12-28 23:37): WHAT: packages/app/src/app/agent/new.tsx:634-643 adds computed labels for provider/mode and packages/app/src/app/agent/new.tsx:729 appends the permissions mode in the agent trigger value. RESULT: agent selector trigger now shows provider, model, and permissions mode. EVIDENCE: Not run (not requested).
  • agent=claude Test 1: Test config persistence via Playwright MCP.

    • Navigate to new agent screen at http://localhost:8081/agent/new.
    • Select a non-default config (e.g., Codex provider, specific model, Plan mode).
    • Create an agent.
    • Navigate back to new agent screen.
    • Verify the previously selected config is pre-populated.
    • If not working, add a fix task with debugging feedback.
    • Done (2025-12-28 23:53): WHAT: Tested via Playwright MCP at http://localhost:8081/agent/new. RESULT: Config persistence working correctly. EVIDENCE: (1) Navigated to new agent screen, (2) Selected Codex provider, gpt-5.1-codex-max model, Full Access mode, (3) Created agent with "hello test" message, agent ID 16354a01-377b-42a5-bf85-b01bbc4c8adc, (4) Navigated back to /agent/new, (5) Verified trigger label shows "Codex · gpt-5.1-codex-max · Full Access" - all settings persisted correctly.
  • agent=claude Test 2: Test permissions mode display in agent selector via Playwright MCP.

    • Navigate to new agent screen at http://localhost:8081/agent/new.
    • Open the agent selector dropdown.
    • Select a specific mode (e.g., "Plan").
    • Verify the trigger label shows provider, model, AND mode (e.g., "Claude · auto · Plan").
    • If not working, add a fix task with debugging feedback.
    • Done (2025-12-28 23:57): WHAT: Tested via Playwright MCP at http://localhost:8081/agent/new. RESULT: Permissions mode display working correctly. EVIDENCE: (1) Navigated to new agent screen, (2) Initial trigger showed "Codex · gpt-5.1-codex-max · Full Access" (persisted from Test 1), (3) Opened agent selector dropdown, (4) Selected "Read Only" → trigger updated to "Codex · gpt-5.1-codex-max · Read Only", (5) Selected "Auto" → trigger updated to "Codex · gpt-5.1-codex-max · Auto", (6) Switched to Claude provider → trigger updated to "Claude · auto · Always Ask", (7) Selected "Plan Mode" → trigger updated to "Claude · auto · Plan Mode". All mode changes correctly reflected in the trigger label.
  • Iteration 3: Filter out internal messages when importing Claude agents.

    • When importing Claude agents, internal messages like "Warmup" are shown.
    • These should be filtered out from the imported history.
    • Add daemon-level E2E test to verify filtering.
    • Done (2025-12-28 23:48): WHAT: packages/server/src/server/agent/providers/claude-agent.ts:1876-1887 skips sidechain history entries when parsing persisted Claude sessions; packages/server/src/server/daemon.e2e.test.ts:2532-2594 adds a daemon E2E that seeds Warmup history and asserts it is not imported. RESULT: Claude import list ignores internal Warmup messages and surfaces real user history. EVIDENCE: Not run (not requested).
  • Iteration 4: Fix Codex import screen showing nothing.

    • Codex import screen currently displays no content.
    • Investigate and fix the issue.
    • Add daemon-level E2E test to verify import works correctly.
    • Done (2025-12-28 23:58): WHAT: packages/server/src/server/agent/providers/codex-mcp-agent.ts:4133-4476 adds Codex persisted session listing from rollout files plus JSON/JSONL timeline parsing and session metadata extraction; packages/server/src/server/daemon.e2e.test.ts:2597-2662 adds Codex persisted agent import E2E coverage. RESULT: Codex import list now populates from on-disk rollouts with timeline previews and is covered by a daemon E2E. EVIDENCE: Not run (not requested).
  • Iteration 5: Add host selector to import agent screen.

    • When importing an agent, user should be able to choose which host to import to.
    • Use the same UI pattern as the new agent screen: host selector in the header.
    • Reference the new agent screen implementation for consistency.
    • Done (2025-12-29 00:05): WHAT: packages/app/src/components/create-agent-modal.tsx:172-2193 adds a host dropdown key, renders the header host badge in the import flow, and adds a host selection sheet; packages/app/src/components/create-agent-modal.tsx:2718-2751 adds host badge/header action styles. RESULT: import agent modal now lets users pick the target host from the header selector. EVIDENCE: Not run (not requested).
  • Iteration 6: Fix gallery 15s timeout causing full-screen error crash.

    • When navigating using the gallery, sometimes a full-screen error appears about a 15s timeout.
    • This appears to be an image loading timeout.
    • The page was showing the directory fine before the crash - this is terrible UX.
    • Fix: Don't crash the page on image timeout. Instead, leave the image in a "loading" state forever or show a placeholder.
    • Image timeouts should never crash the entire view.
    • Done (2025-12-29 00:01): WHAT: packages/app/src/contexts/session-context.tsx:1550-1584 stops updating lastError during file preview requests so thumbnail timeouts no longer trigger the full-screen error state. RESULT: gallery image timeouts no longer replace the directory view; thumbnails remain in loading state. EVIDENCE: Not run (not requested).
  • Iteration 7: Fix spurious loader showing at top of gallery even when directory has loaded.

    • Sometimes the loader at the top of the gallery keeps showing even when the directory content has clearly loaded.
    • Investigate the loading state management and fix the race condition.
    • Done (2025-12-29 00:10): WHAT: packages/app/src/contexts/session-context.tsx:1588-1645 routes back-navigation directory listings through the request helper and clears pendingRequest/isLoading on response. RESULT: gallery header loader no longer sticks after navigating back to cached directories. EVIDENCE: Not run (not requested).
  • Iteration 8: Review and fix file/directory auto-linking logic.

    • Sometimes the agent outputs an absolute path that leads to the cwd but the link doesn't work.
    • It appears the linking logic only accepts relative paths.
    • Review the path detection and linking logic.
    • Fix to handle both absolute and relative paths correctly.
    • Done (2025-12-29 00:15): WHAT: packages/app/src/components/agent-stream-view.tsx:118 now normalizes inline paths using the agent cwd; packages/app/src/components/agent-stream-view.tsx:455 adds path normalization helpers to convert absolute paths within the cwd to relative form before file explorer navigation. RESULT: absolute paths pointing at the agent cwd resolve to the correct directory/file in the explorer. EVIDENCE: Not run (not requested).
  • Iteration 9: Remove host label from git diff screen.

    • The host label is shown on the git diff screen but it's not relevant there.
    • Remove it from the UI.
    • Done (2025-12-29 00:16): WHAT: packages/app/src/app/git-diff.tsx:81-210 removes the Host label from the git diff header and error state; packages/app/src/app/git-diff.tsx:253-307 drops the unused metaText style. RESULT: git diff screen no longer shows the host label. EVIDENCE: Not run (not requested).
  • Checkpoint: Run typecheck and review code quality.

    • Run npm run typecheck and fix any errors.
    • Review all code changes made in this plan (Iterations 1-9).
    • Look for brittle TypeScript: as casts, any types, weakly typed code.
    • Ensure proper type inference and type safety.
    • Add fix tasks for any issues found.
    • Done (2025-12-29 00:18): WHAT: plan.md:97 marked this checkpoint complete; plan.md:106 added follow-up fix task for URL-param validation; REPORT-typecheck-code-quality.md:1 documented typecheck + code-quality findings. RESULT: typecheck passed; identified URL-param cast risk and created fix task. EVIDENCE: npm run typecheck (workspace typecheck completed with exit code 0).
  • Fix: Validate URL-derived provider/mode/model on new agent screen.

    • Guard useLocalSearchParams values in packages/app/src/app/agent/new.tsx.
    • Only accept provider/mode/model values that exist in current definitions/options.
    • Drop invalid values instead of casting to AgentProvider.
    • Done (2025-12-29 00:22): WHAT: packages/app/src/app/agent/new.tsx:37-157 adds provider/mode validation helpers, filters URL params, and applies model params only when available models include them. RESULT: URL-derived provider/mode/model values are validated and invalid inputs are ignored. EVIDENCE: Not run (not requested).
  • Checkpoint: Review daemon test coverage for fixes in this plan.

    • Review all fixes made in this plan (Iterations 3-9).
    • Determine which fixes need daemon-level E2E tests.
    • No mocks, simple tests only.
    • E2E when possible but no browser tests.
    • Add any missing test tasks to the plan.
    • Done (2025-02-10 08:56): WHAT: REPORT-daemon-test-coverage.md:1 documents daemon test coverage review for Iterations 3-9. RESULT: No missing daemon-level E2E tests identified; no new tasks required. EVIDENCE: Review documented in report.
  • agent=claude Investigation: Test image attachment flow via Playwright MCP.

    • Use Playwright MCP to test image uploads at http://localhost:8081.
    • Create a solid color image using ImageMagick (e.g., convert -size 100x100 xc:red /tmp/red.png).
    • Upload the image as an attachment to an agent.
    • Test with Claude agent: ask "what color is this image?" - verify it responds correctly.
    • Test with Codex agent: same test - verify it responds correctly.
    • Investigate how images are being added:
      • Are we uploading images to the server then passing the path in the prompt?
      • Or are we base64 encoding and sending inline?
      • Trace the flow from UI upload to agent prompt.
    • Document findings in the plan.
    • If broken, add fix tasks with debugging details.
    • Done (2025-12-29 09:13): WHAT: Tested image attachments via Playwright MCP; traced code in packages/app/src/app/agent/new.tsx:576-580, packages/app/src/contexts/session-context.tsx:1307-1331, packages/server/src/server/session.ts:316-334. RESULT: Image attachments are BROKEN - three issues found: (1) Agent creation silently drops images with console warning, (2) Web platform fails to base64 encode images due to expo-file-system.readAsStringAsync not working, (3) Server buildAgentPrompt only creates text summary, never passes actual image bytes to LLM. EVIDENCE: Console logs [WARNING] [DraftAgentScreen] Image attachments on agent creation not yet supported and [ERROR] [Session] Failed to convert image: Error: Method readAsStringAsync imported from "expo-file-system"...; agent responses consistently state "I don't see any image attached". Full report in REPORT-image-attachment-investigation.md.
  • Fix: Add image support to agent creation API

    • Extend create_agent_request to accept images array
    • Pass images to handleSendAgentMessage after agent creation
    • Remove warning in new.tsx:576-580 once implemented
  • Fix: Fix web platform image base64 encoding

    • Replace FileSystem.readAsStringAsync in session-context.tsx:1312 with cross-platform solution
    • Use blob URL + fetch or FileReader API for web
    • Test on web, iOS, and Android
  • Fix: Implement multimodal prompt building on server

    • Modify buildAgentPrompt in session.ts:316-334 to return structured content with images
    • Update AgentPromptInput type to support content blocks
    • Implement Claude-specific image content blocks
    • Implement Codex/OpenAI image handling