fix: size controls by the primary pointer, not any touch screen (#9909)

* feat(desktop): size controls by the primary pointer, not any touch screen

The desktop app gave touch-sized controls to every machine with a touch
screen, including Windows laptops driven by a trackpad. In Electron, ask
whether a mouse-like primary pointer drives the UI instead: Chromium
reports a fine primary pointer for those laptops and a coarse one for a
tablet with no mouse or trackpad attached.

Browsers and native keep the touch-screen check, so an iPad keeps touch
sizes with a trackpad attached. Swipe gestures still follow the
touch-screen capability.

Refs #9892

* feat(app): size controls by the primary pointer on every platform

Replace the Electron-only check with one rule everywhere: touch-sized
when touch is the primary input, `(pointer: coarse)`, rather than when a
touch screen exists at all. WebKit keeps touch primary on an iPad with a
trackpad attached, so iPad Safari stays touch-sized; Chromium reports a
fine primary pointer for a touch-screen laptop driven by its trackpad, in
the browser and the desktop app. Native is always touch-sized.

`hasTouchScreen()` and its `maxTouchPoints` fallback had no other caller
and are removed. Swipe gestures still follow the touch-screen capability.

Refs #9892

* test(app): exercise pointer sizing through the media source

* test(app): cover touch laptops with a primary pointer

---------

Co-authored-by: Mohamed Boudra <boudra.moha@gmail.com>
This commit is contained in:
Michael Thomas
2026-11-17 10:48:34 +07:00
committed by GitHub
co-authored by Mohamed Boudra
parent ce09360241
commit e5352c9890
7 changed files with 120 additions and 38 deletions
+1 -1
View File
@@ -76,7 +76,7 @@ Dense toolbar rows, such as the composer's, are the exception to the 44pt contro
In the composer, the first glyph's ink starts on the text column's edge, and the trailing control is always a disc, so the row does not shift as it changes between voice mode, send and stop. The disc nests into the corner, as far from the right edge as from the bottom, and touch-sized the composer's corner radius is concentric with it (`packages/app/src/composer/input/toolbar-rails.ts`). Touch-sized the disc keeps a 6pt clearance from its neighbour, because it is always painted and a pressed neighbour would merge with it. The attach button sits 2pt closer to the picker than its highlight would put it: the plus is all thin arms, so the full gap reads wide. That offset is set by eye.
One gate, `resolveControlSizing`, picks touch or pointer sizing: touch when the layout is compact or the device has a touch screen. An iPad with the sidebar docked is wide and touch-sized; a desktop is pointer-sized; a phone is both compact and touch. The touch-screen fact is read once at startup (`hasTouchScreen` in `hooks/use-fine-pointer.ts`), so attaching a mouse or keyboard to a tablet never shrinks its controls. Stylesheets take sizes from `bySizing({ touch, pointer })`, which resolves to a breakpoint value, so a caller never sees which sizing it got. Rows, icon buttons and icon slots take theirs from `styles/density.ts`, which uses the same gate. An `{ xs, md }` literal for a hit target or glyph is wrong: on an iPad it yields the pointer size.
One gate, `resolveControlSizing`, picks touch or pointer sizing: touch when the layout is compact or touch is the primary input. An iPad with the sidebar docked is wide and touch-sized; a desktop is pointer-sized; a phone is both compact and touch. The primary input comes from `(pointer: coarse)` (`hasTouchPrimaryPointer` in `hooks/pointer-capabilities.ts`), not from whether a touch screen exists: WebKit keeps touch primary on an iPad with a trackpad attached, and Chromium reports a fine primary pointer for a laptop with a touch screen that its trackpad drives. The fact is read once at startup: attaching a pointer to a tablet does not shrink its controls, and a 2-in-1 launched with a pointer keeps pointer sizes after it switches to tablet mode until the app reloads. Stylesheets take sizes from `bySizing({ touch, pointer })`, which resolves to a breakpoint value, so a caller never sees which sizing it got. Rows, icon buttons and icon slots take theirs from `styles/density.ts`, which uses the same gate. An `{ xs, md }` literal for a hit target or glyph is wrong: on an iPad it yields the pointer size.
Buttons are pills (`borderRadius.full`) with medium-weight labels; an icon-only button is a circle. `<Switch>` follows the same two sizes: a 34×20 track by default and in `sm`, 44×26 where controls are touch-sized, and it reserves its size's control height so a row holding one lines up with a row holding a button. Buttons, text fields, dropdown triggers, and `<SegmentedControl>` (`packages/app/src/components/ui/segmented-control.tsx`) share the size contract — the same size name means the same height and label size on every control kind, so controls in one row line up. Segments run tighter than a button, because the gap between segments already reads as padding. The selected segment is a `surface3` fill with `foreground` text, not an inverted one — inverting it inside thin chrome puts a white slab in the toolbar. A settings row sizes the controls in its trailing slot itself, default in a card and `sm` when nested (`packages/app/src/components/ui/control-size.tsx`), so don't pass a size to a button, dropdown or field placed in a row. Code that computes with a control's height outside a stylesheet uses `controlHeightForLayout`. Never shrink a control's font or padding locally to fit a context — if the context needs a smaller control, the size tier is missing or the wrong one is in use.
@@ -0,0 +1,36 @@
import { expect, test } from "../support/fixtures";
import { gotoAppShell } from "../support/helpers/app";
import {
expectFooterActionsInline,
seedDockedSidebarWidth,
} from "../support/helpers/sidebar-footer-overflow";
// Chromium's pointer bitmasks expose both inputs while the mouse is primary.
test.use({
viewport: { width: 1280, height: 800 },
launchOptions: {
args: [
"--blink-settings=primaryPointerType=4,availablePointerTypes=6,primaryHoverType=2,availableHoverTypes=3",
],
},
});
test("a touchscreen laptop keeps sidebar actions visible with a fine primary pointer", async ({
page,
}) => {
await seedDockedSidebarWidth(page, 200);
await gotoAppShell(page);
expect(
await page.evaluate(() => ({
finePrimary: matchMedia("(pointer: fine)").matches,
touchScreen: matchMedia("(any-pointer: coarse)").matches,
})),
).toEqual({ finePrimary: true, touchScreen: true });
await expectFooterActionsInline(page, [
"sidebar-add-project",
"sidebar-usage-icon",
"sidebar-hosts-trigger",
"sidebar-help",
"sidebar-settings",
]);
});
@@ -60,14 +60,8 @@ export function footerOverflowMenu(page: Page): Locator {
return page.getByTestId("sidebar-footer-overflow-menu");
}
/**
* The icon line shows exactly `testIDs`, in order, each `controlSize` square and wholly inside the
* line's box, so no button is cut off by the sidebar's edge.
*/
export async function expectFooterLine(
page: Page,
input: { testIDs: string[]; controlSize: number },
): Promise<void> {
/** The icon line shows exactly `testIDs`, in order. */
export async function expectFooterActionsInline(page: Page, testIDs: string[]): Promise<void> {
const line = footerLine(page);
await expect(line).toHaveCount(1);
await expect
@@ -76,7 +70,16 @@ export async function expectFooterLine(
.locator(FOOTER_LINE_TEST_IDS.map((testID) => `[data-testid="${testID}"]`).join(","))
.evaluateAll((elements) => elements.map((element) => element.getAttribute("data-testid"))),
)
.toEqual(input.testIDs);
.toEqual(testIDs);
}
/** The actions are square and fit inside the line. */
export async function expectFooterLine(
page: Page,
input: { testIDs: string[]; controlSize: number },
): Promise<void> {
await expectFooterActionsInline(page, input.testIDs);
const line = footerLine(page);
const { row, buttons } = await line.evaluate((element, testIDs) => {
const rect = (node: Element) => {
const { x, width, height } = node.getBoundingClientRect();
@@ -68,24 +68,27 @@ const theme = {
} as unknown as Theme;
describe("control sizing gate", () => {
it("is touch-sized in the compact layout or on a touch screen, and pointer-sized otherwise", () => {
expect(resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: true, touchScreen: true })).toBe("touch");
expect(resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: true, touchScreen: false })).toBe("touch");
expect(resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: false, touchScreen: true })).toBe("touch");
expect(resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: false, touchScreen: false })).toBe("pointer");
it("is touch-sized in the compact layout or where touch is the primary input, and pointer-sized otherwise", () => {
expect(resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: true, touchPrimaryPointer: true })).toBe("touch");
expect(resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: true, touchPrimaryPointer: false })).toBe("touch");
expect(resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: false, touchPrimaryPointer: true })).toBe("touch");
expect(resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: false, touchPrimaryPointer: false })).toBe(
"pointer",
);
});
it("gives a touch screen its touch sizes at every width", () => {
it("gives a touch primary pointer its touch sizes at every width", () => {
const sizes = { touch: 44, pointer: 32 };
// An iPad: touch-sized in the docked desktop layout too.
expect(bySizing(sizes, true)).toEqual({ xs: 44, md: 44 });
// A mouse-driven window: touch-sized only once it narrows into the compact layout.
// A mouse- or trackpad-driven window, touch screen or not: touch-sized only once it narrows
// into the compact layout.
expect(bySizing(sizes, false)).toEqual({ xs: 44, md: 32 });
});
it("keeps a device without a touch screen on pointer sizes from md up", () => {
// The unit runtime has no touch screen, which is the desktop that must not change.
it("keeps a device without a touch primary pointer on pointer sizes from md up", () => {
// The unit runtime has no touch primary pointer, which is the desktop that must not change.
expect(controlSizingForLayout(false)).toBe("pointer");
expect(controlSizingForLayout(true)).toBe("touch");
expect(CONTROL_HEIGHTS.md).toEqual({ xs: 44, md: 32 });
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
import { hasTouchScreen } from "@/hooks/pointer-capabilities";
import { hasTouchPrimaryPointer } from "@/hooks/pointer-capabilities";
// The sizing gate, apart from the control sizes so that low-level modules such as
// `constants/layout` can size by it without loading the theme. Import it through
@@ -14,28 +14,32 @@ export type ControlSizing = "touch" | "pointer";
export interface ControlSizingFacts {
/** The layout is below the `md` breakpoint. */
compactLayout: boolean;
/** The device has a touch screen; see `hasTouchScreen`. */
touchScreen: boolean;
/** Touch is the device's primary input; see `hasTouchPrimaryPointer`. */
touchPrimaryPointer: boolean;
}
/**
* The one sizing gate: touch-sized in the compact layout or on any device with a touch screen,
* pointer-sized otherwise. A touch screen keeps touch sizing when a mouse or keyboard is attached.
* The one sizing gate: touch-sized in the compact layout or where touch is the primary input,
* pointer-sized otherwise. An iPad keeps touch sizing with a trackpad attached; a laptop with a
* touch screen that its trackpad drives is pointer-sized.
*/
export function resolveControlSizing({
compactLayout,
touchScreen,
touchPrimaryPointer,
}: ControlSizingFacts): ControlSizing {
if (compactLayout || touchScreen) return "touch";
if (compactLayout || touchPrimaryPointer) return "touch";
return "pointer";
}
// Read once, so attaching a mouse or keyboard later never flips the sizing.
const DEVICE_HAS_TOUCH_SCREEN = hasTouchScreen();
const DEVICE_HAS_TOUCH_PRIMARY_POINTER = hasTouchPrimaryPointer();
/** The sizing on this device for a layout, for code that sizes outside a stylesheet. */
export function controlSizingForLayout(compactLayout: boolean): ControlSizing {
return resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout, touchScreen: DEVICE_HAS_TOUCH_SCREEN });
return resolveControlSizing({
compactLayout,
touchPrimaryPointer: DEVICE_HAS_TOUCH_PRIMARY_POINTER,
});
}
/** A Unistyles breakpoint value: one number in the compact layout, another from `md` up. */
@@ -51,11 +55,11 @@ export type SizingValue = Record<ControlSizing, number>;
*/
export function bySizing(
sizes: SizingValue,
touchScreen: boolean = DEVICE_HAS_TOUCH_SCREEN,
touchPrimaryPointer: boolean = DEVICE_HAS_TOUCH_PRIMARY_POINTER,
): LayoutValue {
return {
xs: sizes[resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: true, touchScreen })],
md: sizes[resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: false, touchScreen })],
xs: sizes[resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: true, touchPrimaryPointer })],
md: sizes[resolveControlSizing({ compactLayout: false, touchPrimaryPointer })],
};
}
@@ -23,10 +23,18 @@ class FakeMediaQueryList {
}
}
function createFakeDisplay(initial: { finePointer: boolean; touchScreen: boolean }) {
function createFakeDisplay(initial: {
finePointer: boolean;
touchScreen: boolean;
touchPrimaryPointer?: boolean;
}) {
const queries = {
finePointer: new FakeMediaQueryList("(hover: hover) and (pointer: fine)", initial.finePointer),
touchScreen: new FakeMediaQueryList("(any-pointer: coarse)", initial.touchScreen),
touchPrimaryPointer: new FakeMediaQueryList(
"(pointer: coarse)",
initial.touchPrimaryPointer ?? false,
),
};
const matchMedia = (query: string) => {
const match = Object.values(queries).find((list) => list.media === query);
@@ -75,3 +83,25 @@ describe("pointer capabilities", () => {
});
});
});
describe("hasTouchPrimaryPointer", () => {
it("is false on a touch-screen laptop driven by its trackpad", () => {
const display = createFakeDisplay({ finePointer: true, touchScreen: true });
expect(createPointerCapabilitiesSource(display.matchMedia).hasTouchPrimaryPointer()).toBe(
false,
);
});
it("is true when the primary pointer is coarse", () => {
const display = createFakeDisplay({
finePointer: false,
touchScreen: true,
touchPrimaryPointer: true,
});
expect(createPointerCapabilitiesSource(display.matchMedia).hasTouchPrimaryPointer()).toBe(true);
});
it("is false without media queries", () => {
expect(createPointerCapabilitiesSource(null).hasTouchPrimaryPointer()).toBe(false);
});
});
+12 -6
View File
@@ -8,6 +8,7 @@ import { isWeb } from "@/constants/platform";
// (detachable keyboards, tablet mode, devtools touch emulation).
const FINE_POINTER_QUERY = "(hover: hover) and (pointer: fine)";
const TOUCH_SCREEN_QUERY = "(any-pointer: coarse)";
const TOUCH_PRIMARY_POINTER_QUERY = "(pointer: coarse)";
export interface PointerCapabilities {
/** A mouse-like pointer drives the UI. */
@@ -21,6 +22,7 @@ type MatchMedia = (query: string) => MediaQueryList;
export interface PointerCapabilitiesSource {
getSnapshot: () => PointerCapabilities;
subscribe: (onChange: () => void) => () => void;
hasTouchPrimaryPointer: () => boolean;
}
export function createPointerCapabilitiesSource(
@@ -28,9 +30,11 @@ export function createPointerCapabilitiesSource(
): PointerCapabilitiesSource {
const finePointerQuery = matchMedia?.(FINE_POINTER_QUERY) ?? null;
const touchScreenQuery = matchMedia?.(TOUCH_SCREEN_QUERY) ?? null;
const touchPrimaryPointerQuery = matchMedia?.(TOUCH_PRIMARY_POINTER_QUERY) ?? null;
let snapshot: PointerCapabilities = { finePointer: false, touchScreen: false };
return {
hasTouchPrimaryPointer: () => touchPrimaryPointerQuery?.matches ?? false,
getSnapshot() {
const finePointer = finePointerQuery?.matches ?? false;
const touchScreen = touchScreenQuery?.matches ?? false;
@@ -61,6 +65,7 @@ const NATIVE_POINTER_CAPABILITIES: PointerCapabilities = { finePointer: false, t
const nativeSource: PointerCapabilitiesSource = {
getSnapshot: () => NATIVE_POINTER_CAPABILITIES,
subscribe: () => () => {},
hasTouchPrimaryPointer: () => true,
};
const source = isWeb ? createPointerCapabilitiesSource(browserMatchMedia()) : nativeSource;
@@ -79,10 +84,11 @@ export function hasFinePointer(): boolean {
return source.getSnapshot().finePointer;
}
/** Touch sizing remains enabled on hybrid browsers that report touch points. */
export function hasTouchScreen(): boolean {
return (
source.getSnapshot().touchScreen ||
(isWeb && typeof window !== "undefined" && window.navigator.maxTouchPoints > 0)
);
/**
* True when touch is the primary input, read at call time. iPadOS keeps touch primary with a
* trackpad attached; a laptop with a touch screen that its trackpad drives reports a fine primary
* pointer.
*/
export function hasTouchPrimaryPointer(): boolean {
return source.hasTouchPrimaryPointer();
}