fix: harden career report producer contracts

This commit is contained in:
Sai-karthik
2026-07-15 19:37:44 +00:00
parent 712a4e57f3
commit 461b893fdc
6 changed files with 184 additions and 30 deletions

View File

@@ -8,29 +8,29 @@ import {
import type { HomeInsightSnapshots, InsightSnapshot } from "../src/v1/analytics/home-insight-snapshot.js";
import type { QscoreProxyResult } from "../src/services/qscore-proxy.js";
const categoryIds = [
"learning_credentials",
"resume_presence",
"linkedin_presence",
"matching_activity",
"interview_performance",
"pathway_progress",
"roleplay_performance",
"engagement_consistency",
"goals_readiness",
const categorySpecs = [
["learning_credentials", "Learning & Credentials"],
["resume_presence", "Resume Presence"],
["linkedin_presence", "LinkedIn Presence"],
["matching_activity", "Matching Activity"],
["interview_performance", "Interview Performance"],
["pathway_progress", "Pathway Progress"],
["roleplay_performance", "Roleplay Performance"],
["engagement_consistency", "Engagement & Consistency"],
["goals_readiness", "Goals & Readiness"],
];
function displayFixture() {
let signalIndex = 0;
const categories = categoryIds.map((id, categoryIndex) => {
const count = categoryIndex === categoryIds.length - 1 ? 3 : 8;
const categories = categorySpecs.map(([id, label], categoryIndex) => {
const count = categoryIndex === categorySpecs.length - 1 ? 3 : 8;
const signals = Array.from({ length: count }, () => {
const index = signalIndex++;
return { id: `signal.${index}`, label: `Signal ${index}`, present: index < 4, score: index < 4 ? 50 : 0 };
});
return {
id,
label: id,
label,
input_ids: [`input_${categoryIndex}`],
weight_percent: 10,
score: signals.some((signal) => signal.present) ? 50 : 0,
@@ -162,6 +162,73 @@ assert.equal(report.sources.find((source) => source.id === "grow_events")?.statu
const malformed = structuredClone(displayFixture());
malformed.registered_signal_count = 66;
assert.equal(parseCareerReportDisplay(malformed), null, "mislabelled canonical display must be rejected");
const reportWithMalformedDisplay = buildCareerReportProjection({
profile: { status: "ready", data: {} },
qscore: { status: "ready", data: { ...qscore, breakdown: { display: malformed } } },
qscoreHistory: { status: "ready", data: [] },
snapshots,
producerStatuses,
activity,
});
assert.equal(reportWithMalformedDisplay.rqScore.display.status, "unavailable");
assert.equal(reportWithMalformedDisplay.rqScore.display.value, null);
assert.equal(reportWithMalformedDisplay.rqScore.display.reason, "display_contract_invalid");
const wrongCategoryId = structuredClone(displayFixture());
wrongCategoryId.categories[0].id = "not_a_canonical_category";
assert.equal(parseCareerReportDisplay(wrongCategoryId), null, "wrong category ids must be rejected");
const wrongCategoryOrder = structuredClone(displayFixture());
[wrongCategoryOrder.categories[0], wrongCategoryOrder.categories[1]] = [wrongCategoryOrder.categories[1], wrongCategoryOrder.categories[0]];
assert.equal(parseCareerReportDisplay(wrongCategoryOrder), null, "canonical categories out of order must be rejected");
const outOfRangeCategoryScore = structuredClone(displayFixture());
outOfRangeCategoryScore.categories[0].score = 101;
assert.equal(parseCareerReportDisplay(outOfRangeCategoryScore), null, "category scores above 100 must be rejected");
const outOfRangeSignalScore = structuredClone(displayFixture());
outOfRangeSignalScore.categories[0].signals[0].score = -1;
assert.equal(parseCareerReportDisplay(outOfRangeSignalScore), null, "signal scores below zero must be rejected");
const outOfRangeWeight = structuredClone(displayFixture());
outOfRangeWeight.categories[0].weight_percent = 101;
assert.equal(parseCareerReportDisplay(outOfRangeWeight), null, "category weights above 100 must be rejected");
const duplicatedSignal = structuredClone(displayFixture());
duplicatedSignal.categories[1].signals[0].id = duplicatedSignal.categories[0].signals[0].id;
assert.equal(parseCareerReportDisplay(duplicatedSignal), null, "signals assigned more than once must be rejected");
const categoryCountMismatch = structuredClone(displayFixture());
categoryCountMismatch.categories[0].present_rules += 1;
assert.equal(parseCareerReportDisplay(categoryCountMismatch), null, "category count mismatches must be rejected");
const malformedOnboarding = buildCareerReportProjection({
profile: {
status: "ready",
data: {
preferences: {
onboarding: {
responses: {
target_role: 42,
desired_outcomes: ["Real goal", 7],
},
},
},
},
},
qscore: { status: "ready", data: qscore },
qscoreHistory: { status: "ready", data: [] },
snapshots,
producerStatuses,
activity,
});
assert.equal(malformedOnboarding.subject.targetRole.status, "unavailable");
assert.equal(malformedOnboarding.subject.targetRole.value, null);
assert.equal(malformedOnboarding.subject.targetRole.reason, "producer_response_invalid");
assert.equal(malformedOnboarding.subject.goals.status, "unavailable");
assert.equal(malformedOnboarding.subject.goals.value, null);
assert.equal(malformedOnboarding.subject.barriers.status, "empty", "missing optional arrays remain confirmed empty");
assert.deepEqual(malformedOnboarding.subject.barriers.value, []);
const unavailable = buildCareerReportProjection({
profile: { status: "unavailable", reason: "profile_unavailable" },

View File

@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
import assert from "node:assert/strict";
import { buildHomeInsightSnapshots } from "../src/v1/analytics/home-insight-snapshot.js";
import type { HomeInsightProducerStatuses } from "../src/v1/analytics/home-insight-snapshot.js";
import type { QscoreProxyResult, QscoreReadResult } from "../src/services/qscore-proxy.js";
function qscoreFixture(): QscoreProxyResult {
@@ -218,4 +219,21 @@ assert.equal(malformedA2a.opportunity.status, "ready", "valid qscore category is
assert.equal(malformedA2a.opportunity.source, "qscore.breakdown.display");
assert.equal(malformedA2a.opportunity.value, 75);
let malformedDirectStatuses: HomeInsightProducerStatuses | null = null;
await buildHomeInsightSnapshots({
userId: "user_fixture",
qscore: readyQscore,
qscoreHistory: history,
recentEvents: [],
onProducerStatuses: (statuses) => { malformedDirectStatuses = statuses; },
}, {
...producers,
resumeState: async () => ({}),
assessments: async () => ({}),
});
assert.equal(malformedDirectStatuses?.resume.status, "unavailable", "malformed resume objects must not mark the direct source ready");
assert.equal(malformedDirectStatuses?.resume.reason, "producer_response_invalid");
assert.equal(malformedDirectStatuses?.assessment.status, "unavailable", "malformed assessment objects must not mark the direct source ready");
assert.equal(malformedDirectStatuses?.assessment.reason, "producer_response_invalid");
console.log("home insight snapshot contract: ok");

View File

@@ -98,6 +98,13 @@ means a successful read confirmed no value or an empty array/count;
expected producer contract is absent. Errors and missing integrations never
become numeric zeroes.
Wrongly typed onboarding values and malformed canonical RQ display payloads
are `unavailable`, never `empty` or `ready`. RQ display validation enforces the
exact nine categories in producer order, all 67 uniquely assigned signals,
and bounded scores, weights, and counts. Activity totals and service buckets
are aggregated across the complete 14-day database window; the bounded recent
event sample is used only as supporting snapshot evidence.
The endpoint deliberately does not calculate labels, rankings, strongest or
weakest categories, recommendations, timelines, peer/market benchmarks,
profile scores, percentages, or narrative prose. It creates no database rows,

View File

@@ -164,7 +164,7 @@ export function v1AnalyticsRoutes() {
? { status: "ready" as const, data }
: { status: "unavailable" as const, reason: "profile_response_invalid" as const })
.catch(() => ({ status: "unavailable" as const, reason: "profile_unavailable" as const }));
const [qscoreRead, qscoreHistory, profile, recentEvents, counts] = await Promise.all([
const [qscoreRead, qscoreHistory, profile, recentEvents, counts, sourceCounts] = await Promise.all([
readQscoreFromService(userId, DEFAULT_QSCORE_ORG_ID),
readQscoreHistoryFromService(userId, DEFAULT_QSCORE_ORG_ID),
profilePromise,
@@ -182,6 +182,14 @@ export function v1AnalyticsRoutes() {
})
.from(growEvents)
.where(and(eq(growEvents.userId, userId), gte(growEvents.occurredAt, daysAgo(14)))),
db
.select({
source: growEvents.source,
count: sql<number>`count(*)::int`,
})
.from(growEvents)
.where(and(eq(growEvents.userId, userId), gte(growEvents.occurredAt, daysAgo(14))))
.groupBy(growEvents.source),
]);
let producerStatuses: HomeInsightProducerStatuses | null = null;
const snapshots = await buildHomeInsightSnapshots({
@@ -193,9 +201,9 @@ export function v1AnalyticsRoutes() {
});
if (!producerStatuses) throw new Error("career report producer status collection failed");
const serviceCounts = new Map<string, number>();
for (const event of recentEvents) {
const bucket = sourceBucket(event.source);
serviceCounts.set(bucket, (serviceCounts.get(bucket) ?? 0) + 1);
for (const row of sourceCounts) {
const bucket = sourceBucket(row.source);
serviceCounts.set(bucket, (serviceCounts.get(bucket) ?? 0) + row.count);
}
const aggregate = counts[0];
const activity: CareerReportActivity = {
@@ -204,7 +212,7 @@ export function v1AnalyticsRoutes() {
completedEvents: aggregate?.completed ?? 0,
openedEvents: aggregate?.opened ?? 0,
services: Array.from(serviceCounts.entries()).map(([service, count]) => ({ service, count })),
opportunityEvents: recentEvents.filter((event) => sourceBucket(event.source) === "opportunities").length,
opportunityEvents: serviceCounts.get("opportunities") ?? 0,
};
return c.json(buildCareerReportProjection({

View File

@@ -102,6 +102,18 @@ export type CareerReportResponse = {
sources: CareerReportSource[];
};
const CANONICAL_CATEGORY_SPECS = [
["learning_credentials", "Learning & Credentials"],
["resume_presence", "Resume Presence"],
["linkedin_presence", "LinkedIn Presence"],
["matching_activity", "Matching Activity"],
["interview_performance", "Interview Performance"],
["pathway_progress", "Pathway Progress"],
["roleplay_performance", "Roleplay Performance"],
["engagement_consistency", "Engagement & Consistency"],
["goals_readiness", "Goals & Readiness"],
] as const;
function isRecord(value: unknown): value is Record<string, unknown> {
return !!value && typeof value === "object" && !Array.isArray(value);
}
@@ -115,6 +127,11 @@ function nonNegativeInteger(value: unknown): number | null {
return number !== null && Number.isInteger(number) && number >= 0 ? number : null;
}
function boundedNumber(value: unknown, minimum: number, maximum: number): number | null {
const number = finiteNumber(value);
return number !== null && number >= minimum && number <= maximum ? number : null;
}
function stringValue(value: unknown): string | null {
return typeof value === "string" && value.trim() ? value.trim() : null;
}
@@ -140,18 +157,22 @@ function unavailableField<T>(source: string, reason: string): CareerReportField<
return { status: "unavailable", source, value: null, updatedAt: null, reason };
}
function unsupportedField<T>(source: string, reason: string, updatedAt: string | null = null): CareerReportField<T> {
return { status: "unsupported", source, value: null, updatedAt, reason };
}
function scalarField(source: string, value: unknown, updatedAt: string | null = null): CareerReportField<string> {
if (value === undefined || value === null || (typeof value === "string" && !value.trim())) {
return { ...emptyField(source, null, "field_not_present"), updatedAt };
}
const parsed = stringValue(value);
return parsed ? readyField(source, parsed, updatedAt) : { ...emptyField(source, null, "field_not_present"), updatedAt };
return parsed
? readyField(source, parsed, updatedAt)
: { ...unavailableField<string>(source, "producer_response_invalid"), updatedAt };
}
function arrayField(source: string, value: unknown, updatedAt: string | null = null): CareerReportField<string[]> {
if (value === undefined || value === null) {
return { ...emptyField(source, [], "field_not_present"), updatedAt };
}
const parsed = stringArray(value);
if (parsed === null) return { ...emptyField(source, [], "field_not_present"), updatedAt };
if (parsed === null) return { ...unavailableField<string[]>(source, "producer_response_invalid"), updatedAt };
return parsed.length ? readyField(source, parsed, updatedAt) : { ...emptyField(source, [], "no_values"), updatedAt };
}
@@ -177,7 +198,7 @@ function parseSignal(value: unknown): CareerReportSignal | null {
if (!isRecord(value)) return null;
const id = stringValue(value.id);
const label = stringValue(value.label);
const score = finiteNumber(value.score);
const score = boundedNumber(value.score, 0, 100);
if (!id || !label || score === null || typeof value.present !== "boolean") return null;
return { id, label, present: value.present, score };
}
@@ -187,8 +208,8 @@ function parseCategory(value: unknown): CareerReportCategory | null {
const id = stringValue(value.id);
const label = stringValue(value.label);
const inputIds = stringArray(value.input_ids);
const weightPercent = finiteNumber(value.weight_percent);
const score = finiteNumber(value.score);
const weightPercent = boundedNumber(value.weight_percent, 0, 100);
const score = boundedNumber(value.score, 0, 100);
const presentRules = nonNegativeInteger(value.present_rules);
const totalRules = nonNegativeInteger(value.total_rules);
if (
@@ -206,6 +227,8 @@ function parseCategory(value: unknown): CareerReportCategory | null {
if (signals.some((signal) => signal === null)) return null;
const parsedSignals = signals as CareerReportSignal[];
if (
totalRules > 67 ||
presentRules > totalRules ||
parsedSignals.length !== totalRules ||
parsedSignals.filter((signal) => signal.present).length !== presentRules ||
value.active !== (presentRules > 0) ||
@@ -224,13 +247,20 @@ export function parseCareerReportDisplay(value: unknown): CareerReportDisplay |
const parsedCategories = categories as CareerReportCategory[];
const signals = parsedCategories.flatMap((category) => category.signals);
if (
parsedCategories.length !== 9 ||
parsedCategories.length !== CANONICAL_CATEGORY_SPECS.length ||
registeredSignalCount !== 67 ||
activeSignalCount > registeredSignalCount ||
signals.length !== registeredSignalCount ||
signals.filter((signal) => signal.present).length !== activeSignalCount ||
new Set(parsedCategories.map((category) => category.id)).size !== parsedCategories.length ||
new Set(signals.map((signal) => signal.id)).size !== signals.length
) return null;
for (const [index, [expectedId, expectedLabel]] of CANONICAL_CATEGORY_SPECS.entries()) {
const category = parsedCategories[index];
if (!category || category.id !== expectedId || category.label !== expectedLabel) return null;
}
const inputIds = parsedCategories.flatMap((category) => category.inputIds);
if (new Set(inputIds).size !== inputIds.length) return null;
return { version: "rq-score-display-v1", registeredSignalCount, activeSignalCount, categories: parsedCategories };
}
@@ -310,7 +340,7 @@ export function buildCareerReportProjection(input: {
const parsedDisplay = parseCareerReportDisplay(input.qscore.data.breakdown.display);
qscoreDisplay = parsedDisplay
? readyField("qscore.breakdown.display", parsedDisplay, input.qscore.data.calculated_at || null)
: unsupportedField("qscore.breakdown.display", "display_contract_missing", input.qscore.data.calculated_at || null);
: { ...unavailableField<CareerReportDisplay>("qscore.breakdown.display", "display_contract_invalid"), updatedAt: input.qscore.data.calculated_at || null };
} else if (input.qscore.status === "empty") {
qscoreScore = emptyField<number>("qscore.current", null, "no_qscore_run");
qscoreDisplay = emptyField<CareerReportDisplay>("qscore.breakdown.display", null, "no_qscore_run");

View File

@@ -262,6 +262,28 @@ function socialStateData(read: ProducerRead): ProducerRead {
: { status: "unavailable", reason: "producer_response_invalid" };
}
function resumeStateData(read: ProducerRead): ProducerRead {
if (read.status === "unavailable") return read;
const count = finiteCount(read.data.resume_count);
const completeness = read.data.resume_completeness;
const status = read.data.resume_status;
const completenessValid = completeness === undefined || completeness === null || (
finiteNumber(completeness) !== null && Number(completeness) >= 0 && Number(completeness) <= 100
);
const statusValid = status === undefined || status === null || text(status) !== null;
if (count === null || !completenessValid || !statusValid || (count > 0 && finiteNumber(completeness) === null)) {
return { status: "unavailable", reason: "producer_response_invalid" };
}
return read;
}
function assessmentStateData(read: ProducerRead): ProducerRead {
if (read.status === "unavailable") return read;
return Array.isArray(read.data.items) && finiteCount(read.data.total) !== null
? read
: { status: "unavailable", reason: "producer_response_invalid" };
}
function a2aData(read: ProducerRead, action: string): ProducerRead {
if (read.status === "unavailable") return read;
if (read.data.status !== "completed" || !Array.isArray(read.data.messages)) {
@@ -316,7 +338,7 @@ export async function buildHomeInsightSnapshots(input: {
recentEvents: InsightEvent[];
onProducerStatuses?: (statuses: HomeInsightProducerStatuses) => void;
}, dependencies: ProducerDependencies = defaultDependencies): Promise<HomeInsightSnapshots> {
const [interviewRaw, roleplayRaw, resumeRead, socialRaw, matchmakingRaw, courseRaw, assessmentRead] = await Promise.all([
const [interviewRaw, roleplayRaw, resumeRaw, socialRaw, matchmakingRaw, courseRaw, assessmentRaw] = await Promise.all([
readProducer(() => dependencies.interviewPageState(input.userId)),
readProducer(() => dependencies.roleplayPageState(input.userId)),
readProducer(() => dependencies.resumeState(input.userId)),
@@ -327,7 +349,9 @@ export async function buildHomeInsightSnapshots(input: {
]);
const interviewRead = sessionPageData(interviewRaw);
const roleplayRead = sessionPageData(roleplayRaw);
const resumeRead = resumeStateData(resumeRaw);
const socialRead = socialStateData(socialRaw);
const assessmentRead = assessmentStateData(assessmentRaw);
const matchmakingRead = a2aData(matchmakingRaw, "scout_stats");
const courseRead = a2aData(courseRaw, "course_state_loaded");
input.onProducerStatuses?.({